Uncertainties over Trump, Ukraine loom large ahead of Asian defense meeting

Uncertainties in theUS defense policy, Ukraine war, and India-Pakistan tensions are set to shape discussions at the Shangri-La Dialogue in Singapore, with key speeches from US Defense Secretary Hegseth and French President Macron

SINGAPORE – Uncertainties over the Trump administration’s security policies in Asia and Europe, the protracted war in Ukraine as well as fresh India-Pakistan tensions are likely to dominate Asia’s leading defense meeting in Singapore later this week.

The Shangri-La Dialogue runs from May 31-June 1, attracting defense ministers, senior military and security officials, diplomats, analysts and weapons makers from around the world.

Analysts and regional diplomats say while a speech by French President Emmanuel Macron on Friday night is the keynote address, all eyes will also be on US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth on Saturday when the Pentagon chief lays out his vision for the Trump administration’s defense policy for the region.

Hegseth will be closely watched by Asian allies not only for his approach towards them, but also how the Trump administration views and articulates the threat from China’s military modernization and ongoing tensions in disputed waters across East Asia.

Analysts expect conversations around the competition between the US and China, maritime conflicts such as the South China Sea, and defense partnerships to also feature prominently.

“Delegates will be eager to hear Defense Secretary Hegseth reiterate America’s commitment to regional security,” said Ian Storey, a regional security expert at Singapore’s ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute.

“But unlike in Europe, there’s no sense of foreboding that the US will draw down its forces in the Indo-Pacific.”

China’s defense ministry has yet to announce whether Defense Minister Dong Jun will attend the dialogue and which other officials it might also send.

The ministry did not immediately respond to a Reuters’ request for comment.

This year’s Shangri-La Dialogue, which is organized annually by the London-headquartered International Institute for Strategic Studies, will also include a special session by Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, who has sought to balance the country’s economic interests with its relationships with both China and the US.

Informal meeting

Analysts and diplomats say that as a freewheeling event, the dialogue often features debates rarely seen in public elsewhere while also providing the opportunity for more discreet bilateral and multilateral talks.

But that informality means it is unlikely to involve any breakthroughs to end Russia’s invasion of Ukraine or resolve disputes between India and Pakistan, for example.

India and Pakistan are likely to be represented by senior military officials at the meeting, and not government ministers, diplomats have said, signalling that no breakthroughs are expected.

Collin Koh, a security scholar at Singapore’s S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, noted that it may be more difficult to get consensus on difficult issues such as the South China Sea, which involves multiple Southeast Asian countries and China, as different countries prioritize their own interests.

He said that the recent imposition of tariffs on US imports could push these countries to negotiate bilaterally rather than multilaterally, resulting in a more disunited approach and playing into China’s hands.

Ja Ian Chong, a political scientist at National University of Singapore, said that it will also be important to observe how the US responds to Chinese maritime actions that appear to have “pushed the envelope” in recent months.

These include the building of structures in the Yellow Sea, known in South Korea as the West Sea, as well as the holding of live-fire exercises on short notice in the Tasman Sea between Australia and New Zealand in February.

“If you have an overly strong response (from the US), it could potentially be escalatory,” Chong said, adding that the current US administration’s unpredictability also makes it difficult to see if it will follow through with any statements it makes.

On the other hand, Koh said that the US is still committed to exercises that have been taking place over the past decade in the Indo-Pacific.

“I don’t see that much trepidation in Southeast Asia pertaining to the US security commitment, even with the ongoing domestic issues taking place,” he said. – Rappler.com